A peer advisory group is a small, recurring circle of people at a similar level who meet to trade honest advice on real business problems. For agency owners and marketing leaders, it works because the people in the room have faced the same decisions you are facing. This Post shows how Andy Milligan set up his first one in Columbus.
Andy is the founder of MMG Design and the Columbus Marketing Organization. In the video above, he walks through the day before his first in-person agency leaders lunch club. It is one of the ways the Columbus marketing community is moving from online conversations into the same room.
"This is my first time ever hosting an in-person event for marketers here in Columbus." Andy Milligan
Why a peer advisory group beats another mixer
Most marketing networking groups are built for volume. You trade business cards, give a 30-second pitch, and leave with a stack of maybes. A peer advisory group is the opposite: fewer people, the same faces over time, and conversations that go deeper than introductions.
That depth matters because people trust people. In a March 2026 study of 1,202 U.S. business decision-makers, SurveyMonkey and Reddit found that peer recommendations were the most trusted source when evaluating vendors, cited by 73% of respondents. The advice you get from a peer carries weight for the same reason.
It also helps with something few agency owners admit. Gallup's 2024 State of the Global Workplace research found that one in five employees worldwide felt loneliness a lot of the previous day, with fully remote workers the highest at 25%. Solo marketers and small agency owners often work exactly that way.
How Andy set up his peer advisory group
The agency leaders lunch club was planned for 18 to 22 people, including guests that attendees brought along. Here is what Andy did before the first meeting, straight from the video:
- He sent a personal welcome email to every attendee. Each person received it individually, though Andy sent them in bulk through his CRM, Folk. He describes it as "personalizing the onboarding and making it as the perfect event for people."
- He removed the friction. The email covered housekeeping: parking, the restaurant, and what to expect.
- He scouted the room the day before. Andy visited the venue and picked a spot with "a couple tables, couple chairs, really good environment to foster some killer conversation."
- He arranged a photographer so the group would have photos from its first gathering.
- He planned personalized letters for everyone who attended.
None of these steps are complicated. Together they tell people the time will be worth it, which is the hardest promise any group has to keep.
What makes a peer advisory group work for marketers
Andy's setup points to a few principles any marketing leader can borrow:
- Keep it small. A lunch table holds a real conversation. A ballroom does not.
- Curate the room. A group of agency leaders talks about pricing, hiring, and client churn in ways a mixed room cannot.
- Make people feel expected. A personal note before the meeting changes how people show up.
- Meet in person when you can. Columbus is large enough to find peers. The Bureau of Labor Statistics May 2025 estimates for the Columbus metro count 2,330 marketing managers alone, before you add agency owners and freelancers.
- Show up consistently. The value compounds when the same people meet again.
If you want to compare structured groups with open ones, read Andy's guide to marketing communities and his honest review of networking groups in Columbus, Ohio.
Finding a CMO network in Columbus
Columbus Marketing Organization is a peer community for marketers, freelancers, and service providers in Columbus, Ohio, founded by Andy Milligan. Members share leads, introductions, and job opportunities, including the weekly Columbus Marketing Jobs newsletter.
For marketing leaders who want a smaller room, CMO runs the Inner Circle, a marketing mastermind for people who want accountability and peer feedback on a regular schedule. Nationally, CEO peer groups and founder organizations offer similar formats. The right choice is the one where the people around the table run businesses like yours.
Start your own peer advisory group
You do not need a big budget to start a peer advisory group. Invite a handful of people at your level, pick a quiet table, send a personal note, and meet again next month. Or see the next Columbus marketing event and join the Columbus Marketing Organization community on Skool to meet peers between events.
This is my first time ever hosting an in-person event for marketers here in Columbus.
Frequently asked questions
What is a peer advisory group?
A peer advisory group is a small group of people at a similar career or business stage who meet regularly to share problems and give honest advice. Unlike a networking event, the same people return each time, so trust builds and conversations go deeper than introductions and pitches.
What are the best mastermind groups for marketing leaders in Columbus, Ohio?
Columbus Marketing Organization, founded by Andy Milligan, runs the Inner Circle mastermind and in-person agency leaders lunches for Columbus marketers. Members share leads, introductions, and job opportunities. National CEO peer groups also exist, so pick the room where the people run businesses like yours.
How many people should be in a peer advisory group?
Small enough for one real conversation. Andy Milligan planned his first agency leaders lunch in Columbus for 18 to 22 people around a few tables. Many groups run smaller. The test is whether everyone can speak, ask for help, and get useful feedback in one session.
How do I start a peer advisory group for marketers?
Invite a handful of peers at your level, choose a quiet venue, and send each person a personal note with the details. Andy Milligan scouted his venue the day before and handled parking and logistics up front. Then meet again on a regular schedule so trust can build.
Read the video transcript
Kind: captions Language: en I'm Andy and you stumbled across my channel where I teach you in public my process for building a $1 million marketing services community empire. This is your first time to the channel, this is the format we usually follow. I start with an up or I start with I start by strategizing in public, telling you everything I'm doing to grow across all three of my businesses. Next, I'm going to be showing you what's working and what is not. So reviewing a little bit of game tape, accountability, action items, what we're going to be doing to improve. And then finally, I'll close you out with an update slashgrowth stats across all the channels that I'm prioritized on growing. So LinkedIn, YouTube, other content updates and things like that. So to start off, I want to strategize in public. This is a very timely update. Current priority is I have the agency leaders lunch club tomorrow. 22 people or 18 to 22 people. I know one guy is inviting four people, but this is my first time ever hosting an Inerson event for marketers here in Columbus. So, what I've done is I've sent out a quick email yesterday just letting people know what to expect. Really kind of personalizing the onboarding and making it, you know, as the perfect event for people sending, "Hey, hope you had a love weekend." actually sent this to each person individually as they received it, but they received it individually, but I sent it in bulk using folk. See what I did there? Nice sort of rhyme. Said little housekeeping. Um, shout out to Eric who's going to be capturing photos, all details regarding parking, restaurant, etc. And I also went there yesterday to visit the place and kind of pick out an area. I think it's going to be awesome. I have a great place picked out kind of on the right side. a couple tables, couple chairs, really good environment to foster some killer conversation. And yeah, I'm also going to be writing personalized letters to everybody and sending that their way as well. Um, business side, I have a meeting here at 12 to be a relatively short video, but I was just reviewing a little bit of game tape on our video DMs now that we've been doing them for a few days now and sent a total of 12 that I think are really wellcrafted. So, we've gotten one response that was a really warm, good response. We've scheduled a coffee meeting with the decision maker at this one. And she's also said that she's bringing it up in a conversation to in a budget conversation for September. And I think our big biggest bottleneck right now is that we're not even getting views or opens. So, if I go to my sent mail, I need to prioritize a prioritize follow-ups now because a lot of these aren't going aren't getting responses, which is really unfortunate, but it's kind of it kind of sucks because they do take a long time and ideally they open them and see them. Deliverability is good so they are landing in inbox. These are verified emails, but our biggest bottleneck right now is getting them to open the video and watch it. So, a few things that I changed just on the CRO side of things is I have prioritized more sending the um keeping it really brief. So, finding a commonality point in the beginning, the Loom video and putting social proof afterwards and also making it much shorter. So, I think this is great. What I want to do is um get a follow-up sequence together just to kind of make it better. Obviously, it's just 12, so it's not even a large enough sample size to really determine if it's working or not. So, I'm going to keep doing it because I think it's a great strategy and it's something that I can control input based goals. So, I'm going to send three more today. Send three every single day. And the thing about these is that they do actually take time. So each of them sending three of them probably takes 45 minutes or so to make it a really good one. But yeah, I have a whole list. When I'm browsing on LinkedIn and I'm connected with with the decision maker at one of these companies, I will add them to the pipeline natively within LinkedIn and it automatically ties the person in the company so that kind of in one shot I can see the company website and the person I'm going to be sending the email to. Bulk does have native enrichment. So, what I've been using this for is going in and hitting enrich. And you can see it will find their phone number. That's something I could do as well is using a cold call as a follow-up sequence. That would be interesting. I thought about getting a business line, but I could use my personal cell as well, just cuz it's remaining small. But, um, yeah, follow-up sequence is going to be the next bottleneck problem to solve because we're landing in the inbox. It's step one. It's personalized and it will get a good response. You just have to see it. So, um, yeah. So, now that we have company emails and things like that, we have her her email now. It does a really good job of finding multiple and I can always use hunter.io to verify as well. So, that's currently what's working and what isn't. On the LinkedIn side of things, my content has not been performing quite to my expectations or um just in terms of, you know, top ofunnel metrics like engagements, impressions, things like that. Our weekly impressions are down a little bit. But something I did want to talk about is I'm trying to open up a I'm getting the foundation set up for opening up a new revenue stream. So, I've gone and I've created a podcast partnership doc. Shout out to Tass Bober who gave me hers as a reference. If you guys have never heard of the Marketers Exit podcast, I was a guest recently. Great show. Tim and Tass do an amazing job putting this together. Highly recommend you check it out. But essentially, uh, I started I landed my first brand partnership with a website AB testing tool. And while it's not a huge contract, it is good. It's $1,500 a month just for a couple newsletters. And I do enjoy making them. So, I'm going to continue to pursue that, built a case study around this. And I put it put together a good foundation here of uh testimonials, audience size. Um I used codecs to manually skim through all my posts for the last two years and add to these. So, while this isn't this isn't completely accurate because it changes technically every day, more posts, more impressions, things like that. I did have a couple posts that went viral that I included as some post formats. podcast um podcast metrics partnership format. So an ad integration webinar short form video including some of the the viral videos that we had pop off last year. Then uh like a website deep dive which went kind of viral too. And then like a text graphic format pricing and packaging. And I'm pricing myself very moderately to start with. 2,000 for a couple post 3,000 for core 5,000 for flagship. If you look at Tasses, she charges exponentially more, but she's also had experience with this, which definitely makes sense. Oops. But this would be cool to kind of unlock this revenue stream. Is it a is it a distraction? Maybe. Probably is. But as I continue to build the newsletter and build the audience, it's going to be a much more compelling value prop. I just have to kind of have this in place. So, um, I'm glad I have this to get started with, and it takes a little bit of leg work off on my end to start this from scratch if a brand were to reach out. I also use Claude to put together um, using a couple resources to put together a list of people that would be perfect fits. So, I have contacts from the tools that we already use like Web Flow, SE Ranking, and other ones that could be a match based on the customers we serve and what we do. So, HubSpot, uh, Pawbox is a healthcare marketing related software. ClickUp is a software I use, notion I use, Gamma, I use, Figma, I use obviously. So, I use a couple resources from JClaus's lab uh, that Justin Moore created. So, if we go into partnerships, I hate this, by the way. Where where do we stand on the best display formats? If anyone uses anything other than tabs like this, the horizontal one, you're just crazy. This is the this is the only way to do it. But a couple resources that I use to put this together is a brand pitch worksheet. So I use a combination of the LinkedIn API called Voyager to find the contacts that matched these company sizes given their brand size, this company titles, these job titles given their company size and also get pitches together using this rope method I put together, which is really cool. Um, so it's going to help me draft all that stuff. I just have to get the outreaches together and this will be working its way into our outreach cadence moving forward. I'll probably make a full video just on doing the outreach itself but and I might create a course at some point on how to get brand partnerships given that this is my current experiment. By the way, what my big vision for this is that I take everything and I package it into courses like on some kind of a community or I just publish it all here for free on the CMO website. To be determined. Right now it's just a newsletter to get jobs delivered weekly. And I also might start start to drip some of this in the in the newsletter as well. Some of my lead generation experiments and outreach etc. So um yeah that is I need to get I have a meeting here at 12 like I said but that would be really cool if we could unlock another revenue stream just from our existing content. And yeah I'm I'm pretty excited about that. It'll it'll be really cool to be able to do that. And while it may not be ludicrous in the beginning, I have spent a lot of time building up this brand equity and getting testimonials and things like that for the podcast. Uh, and speaking of the podcast, I did have one more update. Um, we will be hiring on a different editor for for a different uh editor for each of the podcasts. And that has been my bottleneck is just getting ahead of schedule and really having a cadence in place for getting ahead on the podcast. It's been very weekly. It's been very just the schedule has been driving the work, unfortunately, which is the one thing I preach against. But while we do have episodes recorded, that's never a bottleneck. It has been the production of getting these things out in a timely manner. So, we have multiple saved and not published within Riverside. I do plan ahead as well as I can to kind of get this. We have Angela's next week. And we have a few more in Riverside waiting to be uploaded. I also want to record more solo ones, but again, editor bottleneck means I don't have YouTube content that I can repurpose as a podcast. And obviously the uh the native podcast is falling behind as well. So, we do have several that have been recorded, not published. And if I can just bulk give these to the editor, he's familiar with how to use Riverside can download the footage, create a killer hook and intro, and maybe even make a clip per episode as well, that would be amazing. Then I'm no longer the bottleneck there. Uh, another update on the team. Clark has been doing a good job. We're launching another website this week for uh, 2SP and the site is looking absolutely amazing. Has faced a lot of production bottlenecks with their team and things like that, but just the way the website is looking currently. See if I have the staging uh, here we go. I'll bring up the staging website here real quick. They'll be working and partnering on as a SEO client longer term. So despite all the the headaches and getting this thing launched, it's going to be a great beautiful amazing uh case study that we publish on our website because it is healthcare, you know, athletic sports wellness related and it is gorgeous. So take a look at this nice mega menus. Boom. All six of their locations. Boom. Boom. About nice mega menu as well. Yeah, this is just it's a gorgeous site and I'm truly truly proud of this. We had to look up a hook up a whole CRM integration for this and it's been a mess of complexity that we've had to work our way through here, but they went and like just in terms of all content, gathering team images, etc. We built out their team page. We need to make sure that that link connects to their teams template page. Boom. Yeah. So, making sure that give me a live team member here. Here, Abraham. Boom. Yeah, this looks great. Coolest part that I like about this website is if you go to their footer um the stat the team members dynamically update with all their information on it which is really cool. Um and they all look on brand too as well. So that's pretty awesome. Stoked about that. That and it's just a beautiful design as well. like there's there's no overstating how how valuable the design is and how much it's going to do for their business and yeah, they're going to they're going to be a long-term client, too. So, I'm super stoked to launch this website. All the athletes that they've worked with as well, super cool professional sports teams. Yeah, that is awesome. Yeah, and of course, all their team photos. So, yeah, um that's what I'm doing today. I have to jump on that call here soon. I'll keep you guys posted on the status of sponsorship outreach and how that's going to be working. Opening up a new revenue stream as a business using testimonials, social proof, and our existing content in order to do so. And I will keep you posted. This is day, you know, multiple hundreds um of building this marketing services community empire. Stay tuned for next time. Love you. Talk to you soon.